| Platinum | Buddy's Pizza |
| Gold | Cottage Inn Pizza Saline |
| Silver | Anthony's Gourmet Pizza |
| Bronze | Toarmina's Pizza & Burrito Joint |
| Top Pick | Aubrees |
| Top Pick | Cottage Inn Pizza |
| Top Pick | Jet's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mama Pizza - Ypsi |
| Top Pick | Mani Osteria |
| Top Pick | Pizzapazza |