| Platinum | Common Cup Coffee |
| Gold | Zingerman's Coffee Company |
| Silver | Cinnaholic |
| Bronze | RoosRoast Coffee |
| Top Pick | Argus Farm Stop |
| Top Pick | Big City Small World Bakery |
| Top Pick | Brewed Awakenings Cafe |
| Top Pick | Life Is Sweet |
| Top Pick | Sweetwaters Coffee & Tea |
| Top Pick | The Songbird Cafe |