| Platinum | Village Kitchen |
| Gold | Holiday Restaurant |
| Silver | Uptown Coney Island |
| Bronze | Nick's Original House of Pancakes |
| Top Pick | Avalon Cafe and Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Eat Kerrytown |
| Top Pick | Grand Traverse Pie Company |
| Top Pick | Mark's Mid-Town Coney Island |
| Top Pick | The Jefferson Market |